The Gym's Alpha

Paul was getting a lot of attention when he showed up at our gym. All of the women were interested in him, and I pretty much ignored him until I saw that he rejected the most beautiful woman at the gym. When I saw that happen I knew that he was gay. Still, some of the gay guys in our gym approached him only to be rejected as well. He looked like a typical alpha male, but I began to suspect that he was actually a submissive in the body of an alpha male.
The only man that was a member of our gym that was both bigger than him and gay was me. I knew that I had to make my move on him, and it became obvious to me very quickly that he was destined to submit to me. What I didn't know was that this was his first time with a man, and I felt bad for him for no man after me would be able to match up to me.