Anna Steinhowser

They were best friends. First loves. Soulmates. Until everything shattered. Seth was never supposed to fall for Marjorie-the girl who knew him better than anyone, the one he thought he'd spend forever with. Their love was quiet, intense, undeniable. It was also forbidden. When their families tore them apart, they made a reckless choice: to run. But one impulsive decision cost them everything. Five years.
No calls. No texts. No goodbyes. Now, fate has brought them back to the same place. Same city. Same campus. But everything's changed. Their families are enemies. Their universities, rivals. And the pain they buried? It's bubbling to the surface. Forced to face the past-and each other-Seth and Marjorie must decide:Can you ever really move on from your first love?Or do some hearts never unlearn the way back?When We Were Everything is a heart-wrenching, slow-burn romance about soul-deep connections, second chances, and the kind of love that refuses to be forgotten.